Skip to content

Counter Culture: Time Out Greek & American Restaurant

Cozy Mountlake Terrace gem delivers every time

By Brandon Ferguson April 22, 2025

A comfort food classic, this gyro wrap is filled with sliced meat, tomatoes, onions, and tzatziki sauce, served on a white plate and partially wrapped in newspaper-style paper.
Traditional Gyro.
Photos courtesy of Time Out Greek & American Restaurant

Time Out Greek & American Restaurant, a hidden gem in Mountlake Terrace, has been serving up delicious comfort food since 2004. Founded by Emmanuel and Georgia Flemetakis, this family-owned restaurant is now run by the next generation of the Flemetakis family.

The menu is packed with classic Greek comfort food, offering everything from gyros and souvlaki to falafel and hummus. The flavors are authentic — I can never decide which item I’m going to get. The Greek sample plate, however, is a perfect choice. It offers a little of everything, so it’s guaranteed to satisfy your cravings while avoiding any regret. Other popular options include moussaka, kabobs, and burgers galore as well. In fact, it was previously known as Time Out Burger.

Two plates of comfort food: one featuring a Time Out Burger loaded with bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles; the other showcasing a gyro with fries and a side salad in the background.

A plate of comfort food featuring grilled lamb chops, rice, pita bread, Greek salad with feta, a lemon wedge, and a side of white sauce, served on a white oval platter against a black background.
Paidakia (lamb chops) at Time Out.

Time Out has all the charm of a mom-and-pop operation. It’s the kind of hidden gem that locals adore — nestled just behind Regal Cinebarre Mountlake theater off Exit 177 on I-5. The restaurant embodies the spirit of a classic diner, offering all-day breakfast and indulgent milkshakes in addition to its Greek specialties.

Outdoor seating area with several tables and chairs in front of the Time Out Greek & American Restaurant, perfect for enjoying comfort food like a classic Time Out Burger on a partly cloudy day.A modern restaurant interior with empty tables and chairs, a long bar with high stools, shelves of bottles, and large windows letting in natural light—perfect for enjoying comfort food like the Time Out Burger.

This cozy spot may be tucked away, but it’s more than worth the drive. Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty gyro, a creamy milkshake, or a comforting plate of moussaka, Time Out Greek & American Restaurant delivers every time. It’s a must-visit for anyone who wants a hearty meal in a relaxed, unpretentious setting.

About Counter Culture

Brandon Ferguson is a CFO by trade but a foodie at heart. He has a passion for small, humble restaurants that rarely make it onto the radar of mainstream food critics or glossy dining guides. Join him as he discovers warmth, tradition, and authenticity along with great food.

Follow Us

Restaurant Roundup: Turkey Day and Plant-Based Tuna

Restaurant Roundup: Turkey Day and Plant-Based Tuna

Here’s what was served up recently in the Emerald City.

It’s difficult to write (and likely to read) about eating in Seattle when so many people are about to be hungry after losing SNAP benefits. Toasted Bagel & Coffee, which made headlines last week with their plans for expansion, is doing its part to support the community by launching a free breakfast campaign called “Put…

A Masterclass in Endurance

A Masterclass in Endurance

On a leafy Capitol Hill side street, Single Shot’s chef, Antonio Palma, uses his global culinary chops to make the PNW’s produce shine.

When people talk about Capitol Hill, they tend to overlook its micro-districts. Folks usually think of the well-worn Pike/Pine Corridor first, although a decade ago, it was equal odds they meant the central part of Broadway. But a neighborhood spanning over 11,000 city blocks could never be a monolith. There are boroughs to the Hill….

Restaurant Roundup: Swiftie Brunch and Persian Tea Service

Restaurant Roundup: Swiftie Brunch and Persian Tea Service

Here’s what was served up recently in the Emerald City.

Nadi Mama, one of Seattle’s small-but-mighty restaurant groups, is leaving the industry behind. Its last outpost, Mbar, the rooftop restaurant that wowed guests with sunsets and fine foods from the Levant region, will close following its last day of service on Saturday, Nov. 1. Moving forward, owners will focus on grab-and-go mezze and wraps, which…

A Family Legacy in Every Bowl

A Family Legacy in Every Bowl

For two decades, the Nguyen family’s Pho T & N has been a Poulsbo mainstay built on consistency and community.

When Trinh Nguyen asked her mother, Huyen Tran, what she wanted most after years of running the family restaurant, she didn’t ask for travel or rest. “I just want to be in my kitchen,” she told her daughter. That kitchen, inside Pho T & N in Poulsbo, has been her happy place for 20 years,…